A stacked watermelon, feta and arugula salad is a great summertime starter. Sweet, slightly spicy and a little salty, it makes a delightful presentation served as a salad, either tossed or composed or it can be put on skewers and served as a cool and refreshing appetizer at your next party.
I believe that you are going to enjoy the tasty combination of sweet juicy watermelon, slightly salty feta and peppery arugula topped with a drizzle of honey lime jalapeño vinaigrette. Presented as a salad or as an appetizer, this recipe may soon become one of your summertime favorites. The flavorful combination is very versatile and can be served several ways. For an outdoor barbecue, bring a large bowl filled with watermelon, feta cubes and arugula tossed with the jalapeño vinaigrette. Thinking of having a summer cocktail party, serve the melon and cheese on skewers along with the jalapeño aioli dipping sauce. If you are planning dinner with friends, you might want to serve the recipe as a composed stacked salad perhaps with dots of the jalapeño dipping sauce decorating the plate. The recipe is easy to make and easily adaptable to your own taste.

Spicy Stacked Watermelon, Feta and Arugula Salad
Serves 2 for a light meal or 4 as a composed salad, adjust the recipe accordingly
- 3 Tbsp. Honey Lime Jalapeño Vinaigrette (recipe below)
- 1 chilled baby seedless watermelon sliced into 1/2 inch thick slices then cut into circles
- 2 c. baby arugula leaves (about 1/2 cup, more or less per person)
- 4 oz. feta cheese ( I used part of a 7 oz. imported block of Greek feta packed in brine)
- salt and pepper to taste
To Assemble The Salad:
Cut the watermelon into slices about 1/2 thick. Cut circles (I used a 2 1/2 inch biscuit cutter) out of the slices. Cut the feta into the same size circles with the biscuit cutter then carefully slice horizontally into two pieces. You will need two discs of melon and one of feta for each stack. Place one piece of melon on the serving plate, drizzle lightly with vinaigrette, top with feta. Finish the stack with another piece of watermelon then drizzle lightly with vinaigrette. Place the arugula in a bowl, add a tablespoon or two of the vinaigrette and toss gently. Mound the melon with arugula and serve immediately.
Honey Lime Jalapeño Vinaigrette
- 1 Tbsp. green jalapeño pepper sauce (I use green Tabasco)
- 2 – 3 Tbsp. freshly squeezed lime juice (1 large lime)
- 2 Tbsp. sherry vinegar
- 1 Tbsp. honey, more or less
- 1 Tbsp. finely minced fresh mint leaves
- salt and pepper to taste
- 3 Tbsp. olive oil
Prepared the vinaigrette by whisking all the ingredients together in a small bowl until combined. Taste and adjust the ratio of acid, oil and sweetness to your own preference.

To Assemble As An Appetizer:
Cut watermelon and feta into equal size cubes. Using long toothpicks, spear a mint leaf, feta cube and then a watermelon cube. Serve with the Jalapeño Aioli Dipping Sauce, (recipe below).
Jalapeño Aioli Dipping Sauce
- 1 Tbsp. green jalapeno pepper sauce
- 4 Tbsp. mayonnaise
- 1 sprig of mint, about 6 to 8 leaves, chopped
- Salt and pepper, to taste
Add the mayonnaise, green jalapeño pepper sauce and mint leaves to the bowl of a small food processor. Season with salt and pepper then blend until smooth.
**
Green jalapeño sauce (I use Tabasco brand) is a mild but flavorful sauce with a bright jalapeño taste. You can substitute your favorite pepper sauce but you may have to adjust how much you use.
Adjust the vinaigrette and aioli according to your taste preferences, as written they are just slightly spicy.
The feta that I used was soft and creamy. After cutting with the biscuit cutter, I pushed the cheese halfway out of the cutter and then sliced it in half to retain its shape.
I grew up eating watermelon with a sprinkling of salt as I think it brings out the natural sweetness. If you do use salt, remember that the feta cheese in this recipe will add salt as well.
If you are planning to serve this recipe to a crowd, serve in a large bowl as a tossed salad. Just cut the feta and watermelon into chunks or you could use a melon baller to make cute watermelon balls, add the arugula, drizzle with vinaigrette to taste, toss and serve.
Notes From The Kitchen
****
This colorful and delicious summer salad will impress your guests at any summer dinner party you may be planning. Not only is it pretty but the combination of flavors work so well together. If you want something for a more casual meal, serve the watermelon, feta and arugula tossed in a large bowl with some of the Honey Lime Jalapeño Vinaigrette. For a simple appetizer, serve cubes of watermelon and feta on skewers and serve with the Jalapeño Aioli Dipping Sauce. Anyway you decide to make this recipe, I believe it will become one of your summer favorites, With its tasty combination of sweet juicy watermelon, slightly salty feta and peppery arugula dressed with the honey lime jalapeño vinaigrette, it is sure to please.
I have some watermelons growing right now, and I love feta cheese so this recipe has me smiling.
Great combination. I particularly like the little appetiser cubes.
I made them square, but your round form looks even cuter! A perfect summer salad.
angiesrecipes
http://angiesrecipes.blogspot.com
This looks so good!! and so pretty. Thanks.
Very nice, I will have to try this and share with others. Thanks
What a fantastic twist on a favorite combination!
So pretty! love it.
What a beautiful summer salad and I love the idea of the appetizer skewers, thanks Karen!
Karen, beautiful and fresh with a lovely presentation! It is perfect for summer!
Both presentations of this salad are top notch. Thanks for sharing.
I have made watermelon salad for years with these ingredients. I recently had a similar salad that also had jicama in it. I’ll bet it would taste good with your dressing. I’ll have to try it.
I really like the combo of feta and watermelon, and arugula is always a nice addition. I usually chunk up my watermelon when I make a similar salad, rather than cut nice wedges of the melon and feta. Your presentation is beautiful! I’m SO going to do this. 🙂 Thanks!
Watermelon and Feta is such a great combination. I often make a salad, and even a chilled soup, using it, but never stalked them as you do here. It’s a wonderful way of serving, which I’m sure I’ll be using soon! 🙂
How beautiful this salad looks and I love the ingredients you used to make it.
That look so good! Summery and refreshing.
What a wonderful idea! This would make any meal special, Karen!
This looks not only delicious but beautiful as well!
This recipe is not only delicious but beautiful! Such a lovely presentation.
Have a beautiful week ahead my friend.
That looks sensational – I bet it tastes good too!
Beautiful presentation, Karen! What a delicious combination of watermelon and feta cheese!
Gorgeous…. definitely one to try…..
Karen – I love, nay LOVE, this! So beautiful and the flavors are amazing. Can’t wait to try the vinaigrette, as I think it would be good on a variety of dishes.
This looks amazing!
That looks very inviting for a summer’s day.
this is such a fabulous salad. i have been enjoying nigella lawson’s version for years!
This is a magnificent looking creation, Karen! You are so talented.
Looks amazing! Love the sweet, salty and spicy flavors going on!
I applaud your patience! I would never take the time to do this. Well, when I catered I made pretty things. I just don’t have the ooomph any longer! I’m happy with food that tastes good. Love your recipe!
Such a great combination and it looks so pretty too.
Love these flavours together. So summery. I am sooo looking forward to summer.
The colour is spectacular and I can just imagine how tasty this combination of flavours are.
I love how pretty the fluted ones are. Makes me want to go out and buy small fluted cutters 🙂
Love the little appetizer version of this idea. A “must make soon”. Watermelon and feta are such a great Summer partners. And one more way to use jalapeno dipping sauce. I must try your version.
Delicious idea and I love how you’ve presented it! Just perfect for summer entertaining.
Ohhh you presented this dish really well!
So beautiful, Karen!! And the dressing sounds like a perfect complement to the salad!
Not only are these beautiful but loving this Honey Lime Jalapeño Vinaigrette. Great idea to use a biscuit cutter or cookie cutter to make these cute little salads.
This is such a gorgeous treat, Karen. Looks yummy as well.
Amalia
xo
Watermelon and feta is one of my favourite summer combinations – I can literally have it for weeks! These little stacks look so refreshing and elegant – beautiful!
What a wonderful taste combination, and so beautiful, too!
Beautiful, and also one of my favorite summer dishes.
I can’t get enough watermelon right now. I buy one every time I’m at the market. This is a beautiful recipe — just gorgeous! I especially like the little appetizer version. What a tasty bite! 🙂 ~Valentina
I love the feta watermelon combo and will definitely try it. Thanks Karen.
I love the taste of watermelon and feta combined….your salad looks great!!!……Abrazotes, Marcela
I’m having a total Watermelon-Feta summer, Karen! I can’t wait to try this with the spicy dressing! So much awesome flavor and so beautiful, too!
What a spectacular presentation. Watermelon and feta is on a list of 15 energizing foods in my Dr. Oz Guide. ( The first one!)
Delicous watermelon feta! I love the colorful presentation. 🙂
What a pretty salad! It sounds so tasty with that vinaigrette, too!
So cute! And just when I was saying to myself, “you could even make these bite sized,” I scrolled down and saw them!
I love the way you’ve created and stacked the slices. So cool!